Diamond has released their full February 2014 numbers, and the sales estimates derived from them are showing up at the usual places.
John Jackson Miller has the most comprehensive list over at ComiChron, including the full Top 400 Comics and Top 300 Graphic Novels, plus a few lower items pulled from the charts of the smaller publishers. He also has some commentary here.
ICV2 has the Graphic Novel Top 300 and the Comics Top 300 and commentary.
John Mayo has the charts and some commentary at CBR
Overall a quiet month, down a bit, but not more than you'd expect in a February with no big debuts and Marvel's big event for the season delayed because of a writer change. On the Graphic Novel side, Marvel was doing a bunch of fire-sale liquidations on some older books again, in particular this time their black and white ESSENTIAL line (39 entries) and the smaller (but not quite digest sized) books they tried for a while and confusingly labelled "Graphic Novel Trade Paperbacks" (at least 37 entries). That mass of backlist listings served to squeeze out most of the backlist listings from other publishers, other than the usual suspects, and even quite a few new releases.
I'll have more observations from the charts over the next week.
2014-03-17
2014-03-14
Elsewhere: February 2014 Diamond overview
Somwhat later than normal, Diamond has released their overview of February shipping, and Comichron has a summary and some analysis. Looks like we'll have to wait for next week to get the full Top 300 (or 400) charts. Nothing too surprising in the data released so far. Marvel's quick relaunches of WOLVERINE and FANTASTIC FOUR do okay, not as well as the relaunches less than two years ago, probably both coming in at under 100k, so it looks like that trick is becoming less effective.
2014-03-13
Elsewhere: February 2014 BookScan chart
ICV2 has their monthly look at the Top 20 Graphic Novels as reported through BookScan for February 2014. They've been reporting this information since April 2008, with the past charts listed here. It's a chart of somewhat limited utility, with only 20 entries and no solid numbers attached, and an uncertain definition of "graphic novel", but has some points of interest.
Obviously the usual, lots of WALKING DEAD (in three different formats), lots of ATTACK ON TITAN, the current hit "manga" and the latest volumes of two long-running translated Japanese comics, BLEACH and NARUTO.
The last volume of LOCKE & KEY does well at #5. The two previous volumes each made the chart once and then dropped off, but neither of them were in the Top 10.
ADVENTURE TIME v4 comes in at #7, which is the first time a volume of the series has made the chart, and in fact the first time any book from Boom has made the chart.
Both volumes of SAGA have done well since they were released, making the Top 20 more often than not. It'll be interesting to see how big the third book debuts. It'll only have a brief on-sale window in March if it comes out as scheduled the last week of the month.
Dark Horse continues to do well with AVATAR. In fact, that series represents their only Top 20 books in two years. I'm pretty sure this particular book is one of the $40 "Library Edition" omnibus hardcovers collecting three previous books, so that's an especially good showing.
That MISS PEREGRINE book, a comic book spin-off of a prose and vintage photograph series, looks strange. Contrary to what the ICV2 commentary says, it's actually the second month it's been on the chart, and it actually came out in October 2013, but didn't make the chart until January 2014, presumably boosted by the release of the second novel in the series.
Also, it's not really that noteworthy that DC and Marvel didn't have an entry on the list. Marvel is hardly even a presence on the chart, and while usually DC has a few entries (an old Alan Moore written book, if nothing else) there have been months recently with neither, like March 2012.
Obviously the usual, lots of WALKING DEAD (in three different formats), lots of ATTACK ON TITAN, the current hit "manga" and the latest volumes of two long-running translated Japanese comics, BLEACH and NARUTO.
The last volume of LOCKE & KEY does well at #5. The two previous volumes each made the chart once and then dropped off, but neither of them were in the Top 10.
ADVENTURE TIME v4 comes in at #7, which is the first time a volume of the series has made the chart, and in fact the first time any book from Boom has made the chart.
Both volumes of SAGA have done well since they were released, making the Top 20 more often than not. It'll be interesting to see how big the third book debuts. It'll only have a brief on-sale window in March if it comes out as scheduled the last week of the month.
Dark Horse continues to do well with AVATAR. In fact, that series represents their only Top 20 books in two years. I'm pretty sure this particular book is one of the $40 "Library Edition" omnibus hardcovers collecting three previous books, so that's an especially good showing.
That MISS PEREGRINE book, a comic book spin-off of a prose and vintage photograph series, looks strange. Contrary to what the ICV2 commentary says, it's actually the second month it's been on the chart, and it actually came out in October 2013, but didn't make the chart until January 2014, presumably boosted by the release of the second novel in the series.
Also, it's not really that noteworthy that DC and Marvel didn't have an entry on the list. Marvel is hardly even a presence on the chart, and while usually DC has a few entries (an old Alan Moore written book, if nothing else) there have been months recently with neither, like March 2012.
2014-03-12
Diamond Graphic Novels Chart - Backlist stats
As we wait for the February 2014 numbers from Diamond, an overview of the Diamond Graphic Novel chart and the role of backlist/re-order items on it. For the purposes of this discussion, I'm considering backlist any item making the chart after its initial month of release.
Until 2003, Diamond generally only listed newly released items on its Graphic Novel chart, back when the charts were based on pre-orders from retailers. When they changed to charts based on actual invoiced sales in March 2003, they began including backlist items as well. However, at the time the Graphic Novel chart only went to #50, so there were generally only a handful of books a month making the charts after their initial release, and a lot of new releases didn't make the chart at all.
In February 2004, Diamond expanded the list to 100, which added a few more backlist items making the charts every month, as well as a lot more new releases.
In November 2008 they tripled the list to 300, which is where it's been ever since (I think they might be due for another expansion, with the comics chart having recently gone to 400). At 300 entries, the list generally goes down to about 500 copies or lower in estimated sales, which means that almost all books from DC and Marvel make the list in their first month of release, as do most from other medium sized publishers, although all of them occasionally have a book which will fall below, often expensive books or books where the primary market isn't the North American direct sales market. That also added a lot of backlist items to the chart every month. It varies, but on average it seems you can expect about 60% new items and 40% backlist items on the list.
And of course that backlist isn't evenly distributed. As I discussed before, there are over 100 evergreen books which make the chart more often than not, some of them showing up every month, sometimes making up half or more of the top backlist items. On the other hand, looking at books since the list expanded to 300, over 85% of new books listed will never reach the top 300 again. Another 9% will only reach the list twice. That second entry is often either the month after initial release, which could just be one side of the country getting the book from Diamond a few weeks later than the other due to shipping delays, or over a year later, which often means that the remaining stock was liquidated at heavy discounts. Only about 4% of books have a significant presence on the chart beyond the quarter they were released, and maybe 2% will be likely to still hit the charts a year after they come out.
That doesn't mean, of course, that all those other books don't sell at all. As discussed before, you can reasonably continue to sell some 3000 copies a year through Diamond and still never make the monthly top 300.
Until 2003, Diamond generally only listed newly released items on its Graphic Novel chart, back when the charts were based on pre-orders from retailers. When they changed to charts based on actual invoiced sales in March 2003, they began including backlist items as well. However, at the time the Graphic Novel chart only went to #50, so there were generally only a handful of books a month making the charts after their initial release, and a lot of new releases didn't make the chart at all.
In February 2004, Diamond expanded the list to 100, which added a few more backlist items making the charts every month, as well as a lot more new releases.
In November 2008 they tripled the list to 300, which is where it's been ever since (I think they might be due for another expansion, with the comics chart having recently gone to 400). At 300 entries, the list generally goes down to about 500 copies or lower in estimated sales, which means that almost all books from DC and Marvel make the list in their first month of release, as do most from other medium sized publishers, although all of them occasionally have a book which will fall below, often expensive books or books where the primary market isn't the North American direct sales market. That also added a lot of backlist items to the chart every month. It varies, but on average it seems you can expect about 60% new items and 40% backlist items on the list.
And of course that backlist isn't evenly distributed. As I discussed before, there are over 100 evergreen books which make the chart more often than not, some of them showing up every month, sometimes making up half or more of the top backlist items. On the other hand, looking at books since the list expanded to 300, over 85% of new books listed will never reach the top 300 again. Another 9% will only reach the list twice. That second entry is often either the month after initial release, which could just be one side of the country getting the book from Diamond a few weeks later than the other due to shipping delays, or over a year later, which often means that the remaining stock was liquidated at heavy discounts. Only about 4% of books have a significant presence on the chart beyond the quarter they were released, and maybe 2% will be likely to still hit the charts a year after they come out.
That doesn't mean, of course, that all those other books don't sell at all. As discussed before, you can reasonably continue to sell some 3000 copies a year through Diamond and still never make the monthly top 300.
2014-03-06
BEFORE WATCHMEN sales roundup
One of the more controversial publishing projects of the last few years was DC's BEFORE WATCHMEN. Leaving aside the ethics and aesthetics, let's look at some numbers.
The books were originally published in 37 single issues (making the project, mathematically, over three times better than the 12-issue WATCHMEN) starting June 2012 and, after various delays and changes in plans, finishing in April 2013. Going by John Jackson Miller's estimates for the sales on the year-end Diamond lists for those two years, direct market sales started at over 100,000 for the initial releases (115,500 for the first one, fell sharply after that and then continued to drift down until the final issues sold just over 40,000. So you can place the maximum number of copies of the full story in single issue form around at level, though I know a lot of those final issues are still sitting unsold in comic shops. The average issue sold about 62,000 copies. There were also "digital combo packs" for each issue, but none of them sold enough to make Diamond's top 300, so those wouldn't add much to those numbers (more on digital combo packs in an upcoming post).
We don't have nearly as comprehensive numbers for WATCHMEN CLASSIC, but Miller has dug up numbers for Capital City, one of the major distributors of the time, and they show that single distributor sold an average of over 32,000 copies of each issue just in pre-orders. And instead of losing over 60% of sales from the first issue to the last, it actually gained readers. Since Capital was almost certainly much less than half the direct market at the time, I think we can confidently say WATCHMEN sold much more than 62,000 an issue.
The new comics were collected in four hardcover volumes in June and July 2013. They shipped an average of just over 4000 copies each in the initial month of release, and by the end of the year were at an average of just over 5000 copies each.
So Diamond's "over 3,500 accounts" were scrambling to meet demand for the books to the tune of under 200 copies per book per month, on average.
The books were originally published in 37 single issues (making the project, mathematically, over three times better than the 12-issue WATCHMEN) starting June 2012 and, after various delays and changes in plans, finishing in April 2013. Going by John Jackson Miller's estimates for the sales on the year-end Diamond lists for those two years, direct market sales started at over 100,000 for the initial releases (115,500 for the first one, fell sharply after that and then continued to drift down until the final issues sold just over 40,000. So you can place the maximum number of copies of the full story in single issue form around at level, though I know a lot of those final issues are still sitting unsold in comic shops. The average issue sold about 62,000 copies. There were also "digital combo packs" for each issue, but none of them sold enough to make Diamond's top 300, so those wouldn't add much to those numbers (more on digital combo packs in an upcoming post).
We don't have nearly as comprehensive numbers for WATCHMEN CLASSIC, but Miller has dug up numbers for Capital City, one of the major distributors of the time, and they show that single distributor sold an average of over 32,000 copies of each issue just in pre-orders. And instead of losing over 60% of sales from the first issue to the last, it actually gained readers. Since Capital was almost certainly much less than half the direct market at the time, I think we can confidently say WATCHMEN sold much more than 62,000 an issue.
The new comics were collected in four hardcover volumes in June and July 2013. They shipped an average of just over 4000 copies each in the initial month of release, and by the end of the year were at an average of just over 5000 copies each.
| Title | First Month Estimate | Year End Estimate | Reorders per month Estimate |
| BW Comedian Rorschach HC | 4,443 | 5,700 | 251 |
| BW Minutemen Silk Spectre HC | 3,939 | 5,100 | 194 |
| BW Nite Owl Dr Manhattan HC | 4,076 | 4,800 | 145 |
| BW Ozymandias Crimson Corsair HC | 3,705 | 4,600 | 149
|
| Average BW book | 4,041 | 5,050 | 185 |
So Diamond's "over 3,500 accounts" were scrambling to meet demand for the books to the tune of under 200 copies per book per month, on average.
Of course, there's always the mass market. According to the Bookscan numbers Brian Hibbs supplies, COMEDIAN sold 4,948 in their reporting markets, NITE OWL sold 3,407 and MINUTEMEN sold 3,180. OZYMANDIAS didn't make the top 750 that Hibbs posted, so all we can say is that it's less than 2,660 copies, so the books average under 3,600 copies. They also don't appear to have ever been on Amazon's Top 50 based on Dave Carter's charts, though a few of them did briefly show up on the New York Times hardcover graphic books chart.
Again, we don't know how the original did, but again from Miller's look at Capital's numbers "Initial orders for the first printing were 7,650 copies at Capital, with the second printing getting initial orders of 2,335 copies", so that's almost 10,000 copies sold in short order from just one of several direct market distributors, plus it was known to be one of the most impressive sellers in the mass market in that era.
We do have some idea of how the original continues to sell. It's available in four different print editions: the standard softcover, the "international edition" softcover, the deluxe hardcover and the Absolute edition. Over the past decade, those editions have sold well over 1.3 million copies combined in the direct market and BookScan reporting mass market. That's heavily weighted towards the years when the film adaptation was in the news of course, especially before people actually saw the movie, but even in 2013 it sold well over 40,000 copies in those markets, in its 27th straight year of availability.
There's also the black box of digital, where there are no real solid numbers for even a portion of the market, but we can see that while WATCHMEN proper is #13,129 today on Amazon's Kindle store, the BEFORE WATCHMEN books range from #139,947 to #440,624. I don't think it's too much of a stretch to assume that the original book is selling multiple times what the new books are in that particular market, probably more than all four combined.
(note, someone sent me this link to a post by author Theresa Ragan estimating Kindle rankings sales levels based on her own experiences. They seem to indicate the BW books are selling less than a copy a day, while WATCHMEN is in the higher end of the "5 to 15 books a day" range).
We obviously don't know enough about the internal calculations at DC and the total numbers to declare the project a profit or loss, but it's hard not to see them as disappointing for something as well publicized as this. There are fewer than 60,000 print copies of the whole story sold to those markets we get decent numbers for, numbers that the original book can match in a good year. That can't be what they went in thinking they'd be happy with.
Now of course, we still have the paperback editions of BEFORE WATCHMEN coming out in a few months, and that's the format where the original book has seen most of its sales over the years, so there's a chance a larger audience is waiting for the books in their preferred format and price point. There might be a price drop on the digital versions when the paperbacks come out as well, which might get them selling up to a copy a day.We'll get an idea if that's the case over the next year.
There's also the black box of digital, where there are no real solid numbers for even a portion of the market, but we can see that while WATCHMEN proper is #13,129 today on Amazon's Kindle store, the BEFORE WATCHMEN books range from #139,947 to #440,624. I don't think it's too much of a stretch to assume that the original book is selling multiple times what the new books are in that particular market, probably more than all four combined.
(note, someone sent me this link to a post by author Theresa Ragan estimating Kindle rankings sales levels based on her own experiences. They seem to indicate the BW books are selling less than a copy a day, while WATCHMEN is in the higher end of the "5 to 15 books a day" range).
We obviously don't know enough about the internal calculations at DC and the total numbers to declare the project a profit or loss, but it's hard not to see them as disappointing for something as well publicized as this. There are fewer than 60,000 print copies of the whole story sold to those markets we get decent numbers for, numbers that the original book can match in a good year. That can't be what they went in thinking they'd be happy with.
Now of course, we still have the paperback editions of BEFORE WATCHMEN coming out in a few months, and that's the format where the original book has seen most of its sales over the years, so there's a chance a larger audience is waiting for the books in their preferred format and price point. There might be a price drop on the digital versions when the paperbacks come out as well, which might get them selling up to a copy a day.We'll get an idea if that's the case over the next year.
2014-03-04
Diamond Graphic Novels Chart - Below the Top 300
Since I spent a few posts talking about books that almost always show up on Diamond's Top 300 Graphic Novel chart, I figured it was worth looking at examples of books that never do, but still sell well, just to emphasize the importance of the so-called "long tail" and the fact that the Top 300 isn't everything.
Some background. Diamond currently reports the Top 300 books they categorize as graphic novels every month, plus some months their "small publishers" chart includes a few more entries below #300. This includes both new releases and backlist items. The cut-off for appearing on the list varies, of course. In 2013 estimates of sales of the #300 book ranged from 327 copies to 510 copies. What this means is that theoretically a book could have come in at #301 every month, tied with the book above it, shipped 4963 copies and yet never appear on the Top 300. Of course, that's statistically unlikely.
However, Diamond also releases a Top 1000 for the full year. On the Comics side there are no real surprises, it goes down to 27,800 copies estimated sales, so it's pretty much stuff that was in the Top 100 every month, with a few books moving up or down a few spots from what you'd expect based on the monthly charts, indicating a few thousand reorders or later printings falling below the Top 300, or adjustments for returns.
The graphic novel list, on the other hand, goes down to 1600 copies, and the nature of the market means it's perfectly feasible for books which rarely if ever make the top 300 in any single month to make that chart, just by selling more than an average of 133 copies a month. That might not seem like a lot of copies, but 1600 copies a year, just in the non-returnable direct market, for a book where all the initial creative and production costs are paid for is probably a decent enough sales velocity for most publishers to keep a book in stock, and probably call for a new printing when sold out.
It's hard to do an exact count, since Diamond often makes small changes in the listed titles of books, but I'd say there are a little over 100 books on the yearly Top 1000 for 2013 which were never on the monthly charts during the year.
The highest of those appears to be Marvel's FEAR ITSELF TP, a collection of the 2011 crossover event. It ranked #392 for the year, selling around 3100 copies, or slightly over 250 each month on average.
Just a few more highlights from books in this category, starting with Marvel since we're already there. I've identified 23 Marvel books, and almost one-third of them are Deadpool books. A few older best-sellers like WOLVERINE ORIGIN, MARVEL 1602 and HULK: WORLD WAR HULK are also there, as is the hardcover edition of the CIVIL WAR crossover which also sells well in softcover. There's one collection of older material the first Marvel Masterworks edition of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN, which sells about 1700 copies for the year.
As you'd expect, DC has a most of the books in this category, many under the Vertigo imprint which is known for its vigorous backlist program. The top one is Y THE LAST MAN VOL 4 SAFEWORD, selling around 3000 copies (250 a month), with the prior volumes selling more and making the Top 300 at least once and the next six volumes selling enough to make the annual Top 1000, with VOL 10 selling around 1700 copies. There are also multiple volumes of FABLES, TRANSMETROPOLITAN, AMERICAN VAMPIRE, SWEET TOOTH and single volumes of several other Vertigo series, with the later ones probably selling steadily at a slightly lower rate.
On the DC super-hero side, lots of Batman, some Green Lantern, several of the old "Crisis" books (CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS, IDENTITY CRISIS, INFINITE CRISIS). The first volume of the kids book TINY TITANS still sells at a steady pace, with about 2200 copies in the direct market several years after it was first published.
Image and Dark Horse both have a number of books in this category. From Image it's a selection of WALKING DEAD hardcovers, a few volumes of MORNING GLORIES and single volumes of SPAWN, INVINCIBLE and KING CITY. Dark Horse has several BUFFY books and single early volumes of THE GOON, AXE COP, SIN CITY, MASS EFFECT and STAR WARS CLONE WARS.
Various other publishers have one or two books. Archaia has two MOUSE GUARD books, Avatar has the second CROSSED book and NEONOMICON. Dynamite has the first two volumes of THE BOYS. IDW has the first volume of the current TMNT series and the second hardcover volume of LOCKE AND KEY.
Other publishers have single volumes of SCOTT PILGRIM (Oni), BLACK BUTLER (Yen), ASSASSIN'S CREED (Titan) and LEGEND OF ZELDA (Viz).
Some background. Diamond currently reports the Top 300 books they categorize as graphic novels every month, plus some months their "small publishers" chart includes a few more entries below #300. This includes both new releases and backlist items. The cut-off for appearing on the list varies, of course. In 2013 estimates of sales of the #300 book ranged from 327 copies to 510 copies. What this means is that theoretically a book could have come in at #301 every month, tied with the book above it, shipped 4963 copies and yet never appear on the Top 300. Of course, that's statistically unlikely.
However, Diamond also releases a Top 1000 for the full year. On the Comics side there are no real surprises, it goes down to 27,800 copies estimated sales, so it's pretty much stuff that was in the Top 100 every month, with a few books moving up or down a few spots from what you'd expect based on the monthly charts, indicating a few thousand reorders or later printings falling below the Top 300, or adjustments for returns.
The graphic novel list, on the other hand, goes down to 1600 copies, and the nature of the market means it's perfectly feasible for books which rarely if ever make the top 300 in any single month to make that chart, just by selling more than an average of 133 copies a month. That might not seem like a lot of copies, but 1600 copies a year, just in the non-returnable direct market, for a book where all the initial creative and production costs are paid for is probably a decent enough sales velocity for most publishers to keep a book in stock, and probably call for a new printing when sold out.
It's hard to do an exact count, since Diamond often makes small changes in the listed titles of books, but I'd say there are a little over 100 books on the yearly Top 1000 for 2013 which were never on the monthly charts during the year.
The highest of those appears to be Marvel's FEAR ITSELF TP, a collection of the 2011 crossover event. It ranked #392 for the year, selling around 3100 copies, or slightly over 250 each month on average.Just a few more highlights from books in this category, starting with Marvel since we're already there. I've identified 23 Marvel books, and almost one-third of them are Deadpool books. A few older best-sellers like WOLVERINE ORIGIN, MARVEL 1602 and HULK: WORLD WAR HULK are also there, as is the hardcover edition of the CIVIL WAR crossover which also sells well in softcover. There's one collection of older material the first Marvel Masterworks edition of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN, which sells about 1700 copies for the year.
As you'd expect, DC has a most of the books in this category, many under the Vertigo imprint which is known for its vigorous backlist program. The top one is Y THE LAST MAN VOL 4 SAFEWORD, selling around 3000 copies (250 a month), with the prior volumes selling more and making the Top 300 at least once and the next six volumes selling enough to make the annual Top 1000, with VOL 10 selling around 1700 copies. There are also multiple volumes of FABLES, TRANSMETROPOLITAN, AMERICAN VAMPIRE, SWEET TOOTH and single volumes of several other Vertigo series, with the later ones probably selling steadily at a slightly lower rate.On the DC super-hero side, lots of Batman, some Green Lantern, several of the old "Crisis" books (CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS, IDENTITY CRISIS, INFINITE CRISIS). The first volume of the kids book TINY TITANS still sells at a steady pace, with about 2200 copies in the direct market several years after it was first published.
Image and Dark Horse both have a number of books in this category. From Image it's a selection of WALKING DEAD hardcovers, a few volumes of MORNING GLORIES and single volumes of SPAWN, INVINCIBLE and KING CITY. Dark Horse has several BUFFY books and single early volumes of THE GOON, AXE COP, SIN CITY, MASS EFFECT and STAR WARS CLONE WARS.Various other publishers have one or two books. Archaia has two MOUSE GUARD books, Avatar has the second CROSSED book and NEONOMICON. Dynamite has the first two volumes of THE BOYS. IDW has the first volume of the current TMNT series and the second hardcover volume of LOCKE AND KEY.
Other publishers have single volumes of SCOTT PILGRIM (Oni), BLACK BUTLER (Yen), ASSASSIN'S CREED (Titan) and LEGEND OF ZELDA (Viz).
What the Dinosaurs Read... (part 4)
I've already looked at THE COMIC READER's Top 100 chart for March of 1979, 1980 and 1981. Unfortunately the chart didn't last until March of 1982, so I'll just look at what appears to be the last chart they ran, for September 1981 and appearing in TCR #199 (editor: Michael Tiefenbacher publisher: Jerome Sinkovec). Here's a decent list of comics published that month.
Without any big launches, X-MEN has its usual comfortable lead up top. DC's NEW TEEN TITANS is #2. DC also has a few more recent launches doing well, ALL-STAR SQUADRON and ARAK. Not too much of a surprise that DC's top books all have key people who had recently left Marvel.
We hit the first non-DC/Marvel book more quickly than usual, with the second issue of Jack Kirby's CAPTAIN VICTORY from Pacific at #23.DC's turn to do the DC/Marvel crossover, with the Batman/Hulk tabloid at #34. The $2.50 cover price, when most comics were $0.50 or $0.60, means it was probably the top book at retail. At $2 each, THE SPIRIT (published by Kitchen Sink, with the "Spirit Jam" issue) and HEAVY METAL are up there in dollar terms compared to their middle of the chart unit rankings.
At #53 we get a first issue (actually a one-shot), SPIDER-MAN AND HIS AMAZING FRIENDS, based on the cartoon of the same name. The other first issue on the chart is Whitman's CONDORMAN, adapting the Disney movie.
Not too many other notables on the list, just the usual mix of Whitman and Harvey comics, followed by Archie at the tail end of the top 100. MAD MAGAZINE does show up at #79, selling less than CRAZY a few positions above it. That's probably one of the few markets where you could say CRAZY outsold MAD and not be accused of being cracked.So what can we learn from these charts? WARLORD was much more popular than I thought. Marvel heavily dominated the market from early on, It took DC picking up some creators driven out of Marvel to begin to erode that dominance. First issues were still infrequent at this point, but when they were published you can already see the evolution of the huge launch followed by a massive second issue drop. And of course there's the increasing value of having your most popular characters (at that time the X-Men, not yet specifically Wolverine) do guest star roles.
Anyway, the whole thing was an interesting experiment. I'm not sure when we next saw a decent sales chart for the direct market. I think AMAZING HEROES ran a similar one a few years later, but my collection of those is sketchy. If I can dig one up I'll post it. By the mid-1980s the comic shop distribution had solidified enough that there were several big established distributors, like Capital and Diamond, and eventually they were releasing some charts about what they sold, generally using index values tied to percentages of key books. I think the COMICS BUYER'S GUIDE ran charts based on that occasionally, and their publisher had a magazine called COMICS RETAILER which I'm sure must have run those numbers. After a few years and various odd events Diamond became practically a monopoly in direct market distribution, so using its chart, with knowledge of actual sales of a few books, gives a pretty clear general picture of the direct market from the mid-1990s on.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

